St. Augustine combines coastal wind exposure with a large stock of historic and older masonry homes, and both drive underwriting here. Downtown and low-lying areas near the Matanzas and San Sebastian rivers flood, so flood insurance is a practical necessity well beyond the mandatory zones.
St. Johns County is the northern edge of our service area. St. Augustine's mix of historic downtown properties, Anastasia Island beachside homes and newer inland subdivisions means there is no single underwriting story for the city.
ZIP codes served: 32080, 32084, 32086, 32095
Pick everything you'd like quoted — we'll only ask what's relevant.
Homes built before modern codes need replacement cost figures that reflect period materials and craftsmanship, plus ordinance-and-law coverage sized for a rebuild that has to meet current code. Standard limits are frequently far too low here.
Areas near the Matanzas and San Sebastian rivers have a documented history of tidal and surge flooding. Flood coverage is separate from homeowners in every case.
Island properties are rated in the tightest distance-to-coast band, and opening protection carries the largest single credit available on those policies.
St. Augustine has a heavy vacation-rental market. A homeowners policy does not respond to commercial rental activity; those properties need a landlord or short-term rental form with matching liability.
It takes more work but is very doable. The key is an accurate replacement cost that reflects period construction, plus ordinance-and-law coverage sized to bring a rebuild up to current code. Some carriers avoid the class entirely, which is exactly where an independent agency helps.
In mapped A and V zones with a federally backed mortgage, yes, it is required. Given the city's tidal flooding history, we recommend it even in X zones, where preferred-risk premiums are low.
Yes. Short-term rental properties need a policy form written for that use, including liability appropriate to paying guests. A standard homeowners policy can be denied at claim time if the property is rented commercially.